AUTHORS
Jessica Skinner, Natalie Langley, Samuel Fahrenholtz, Yuktha Shanavas, Brian Waletzki, Robert Brown, James Herrick, Loukham Shyamsunder, Peter Goguen, Subramaniam Rajan
ABSTRACT
This study investigated if microscopic surface features captured with a scanning electron microscope (SEM) effectively discriminate fracture timing. We hypothesized that microscopic fracture characteristics, including delamination, osteon pullout, and microcracks, may vary as bone elasticity decreases, elucidating perimortem and postmortem events more reliably than macroscopic analyses. Thirty-seven unembalmed, defleshed human femoral shafts from males (n=18) and females (n=2) aged 33–81 years were fractured at experimentally simulated postmortem intervals (PMIs) ranging from 1 to 60 warm weather days (250–40,600 ADH). A gravity convection oven was used to approximate tissue decomposition at 37 C and 27 C, and the resulting heat-time unit (accumulated degree hours, or ADH) was used to examine fractures in elastic/wet versus brittle/dry bone. The bones were fractured with a drop test frame using a three-point bending setup, sensors were used to calculate fracture energy, and high-speed photography documented fracture events. The following data were collected to relate fracture appearance to the biomechanical properties of bone: PMI (postmortem interval) length in ADH, temperature, humidity, collagen percentage, water loss, bone mineral density, cortical bone thickness, fracture energy, age, sex, cause of death, and microscopic fracture feature scores. SEM micrographs were collected from the primary tension zones of each fracture surface, and three microscopic fracture characteristics were scored from a region of interest in the center of the tension zone: percentage of delaminated osteons, percent osteon pullout, and number of microcracks. Multiple linear regression showed that microscopic fracture surface features are strong predictors of ADH (adjusted R-squared=0.67 for the 0 – 40,000 ADH samples; adjusted R-squared=0.92 for the 0–16,000 ADH samples). Osteon pullout is the single best predictor of ADH. Additionally, water loss is the primary driver of bone elasticity changes in low ADH samples, while collagen fibers appear to remain intact until later in the postmortem interval (approximately 40,000 ADH in this study). The results of this study indicate microscopic fracture surface analysis detects the biomechanical effects of decreased elasticity more reliably and with greater sensitivity than macroscopic analysis.